Daniel Landes' review of Arthur Green's Radical Judaism: Rethinking God and Tradition reminds me of my own tension with Orthodoxy: Green admits, "(partly in sadness!) that it no longer suffices for me to limit my sense of spiritual fellowship to those who fall within the ethnic boundaries that history has given us." He is, indeed, prepared to say: "I have more in common with seekers and strugglers of other faiths than I do with either the narrowly and triumphally religious as the secular and materialistic elements within my own community." Thus Green calls for a broader "Israel," imagining "an extended faith-community of Israel, a large outer courtyard of our spiritual Temple." Although Green himself is a person who is clearly attached to the Jewish people, the logic of his position is disturbing. It leads him to privilege people possessing the proper spiritual consciousness, "my Israel," over the actual people of Israel. So G...
"Wherever the spirit would go, they went, and the wheels rose along with them; for the spirit of the living creatures was in the wheels."
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that you quoted this passage.
You may know Alexander Isaievitch Solzhenitsyn wrote a great number of volumes on the bolshevik revolution entitled the "red wheel" where the wheel i.e. the machine is in fact seen as crushing men, and spirit. In Ezekiel's vision everything is being reversed. Spirit dominates matter. In fact this reminds me of a little known text by Vassili Grossman, one he wrote after having contemplated the famous work by Raphael (http://www.skd-dresden.de/media/300_sixtina.jpg) before it being sent back to Germany in 1955.
If you read french:
"Un récit de 1955, La Madone Sixtine, livre une clé pour l'oeuvre : le tableau de Raphaël, tant aimé par Dostoïevski, fut exposé à Moscou avant d'être restitué à Dresde. Staline inspecte le tableau en caressant ses moustaches. Grossman à son tour s'approche du tableau et voit la jeune Madone au regard si triste, l'enfant si grave, il aperçoit « la force d'esprit qui se matérialise », une énergie qui se fait chair et qui inverse la découverte d'Einstein, il voit Treblinka, Kolyma, toute son oeuvre future."